Novel Thoughts blog

Graham Greene’s Cobbled Road from St. Mary’s

July 28, 2015 3:48 pm | 3 Comments


Graham Greene, often mentioned in these pages, had a troubled and chaotic relationship with the Catholic faith to which he converted the year before his marriage, so much so that his motives for conversion have even been questioned. At the same time, more than any writer of his day, he wrote novels rich in Catholic themes seeming to reflect his personal moral conflicts, some of which were British tabloid news of his era.

Absent his problematic Catholicism, would the Greene we know today, be recognizable at all?

Perhaps Greene wrote about matters Catholic precisely because by some standards he was not a very good one. His faith was the shoe that did not quite fit. His novels endure for the very reason that he had more questions than answers, more doubts than convictions, and found more pain than most as he limped his way along. It’s a strange business, though, for a writer to wander into a world where he could feel so little at home and ultimately found so little comfort.

His conversion made him the novelist he was. His struggle with matters Catholic may have been all the more penetrating because of his own misgivings and lapses. He was not reluctant to wade into murky waters where his lean prose belies his struggle to simply stay afloat.

Complacency might make for a good night’s rest, but it never leads to much when it comes to writing once morning arrives. And it never makes for a good novel.

My wife and I encountered the Graham Greene story in a personal sense, at almost its beginning when we lived in Hampstead a few years ago, and attended Mass at St. Mary’s Church. The church, itself no larger than a chapel, had been established to serve Catholic refugees fleeing the French Revolution at the end of the eighteenth century. Later on, French President Charles de Gaulle worshipped there, from a first-row pew, while awaiting the defeat of German occupiers of France and otherwise annoying Winston Churchill. Already, the marriage of Graham Greene and Vivien Dayrell-Browning at St. Mary’s Hampstead in 1927 had become local lore in this most literary of London villages.

It would be challenging to find anywhere in London a more romantic and historical setting for a wedding, on a hilltop overlooking London, in storied Hampstead, this tiny white-painted chapel of a French-Spanish design. Gas lights flank a cobbled walkway uphill past a cemetery to the church front where a statue of the Blessed Virgin, high in its façade, has looked out upon generations of Catholic expat history and Catholic creative endeavors, both foreign and native. Robert Louis Stevenson for a time lived up the hill and around a corner.

All this atmospheric stuff notwithstanding, the Greene’s marriage failed, a split in all but the official sense. Meantime Greene wrote on and on and on. Years later and for a long time hence, we will be grateful that he did so, and grateful for the abiding sense of his troubled Catholicism. He led his readers down shadowy paths of personal crisis, illuminated but half-lit, with something –a suspicion, a doubt, a scruple, an irony—always lurking.

Cows and goats have more than one stomach, and so are classified as ruminants. Bi-polarity makes ruminants of artists like Greene. Ruminants pass what they consume from one stomach to another, and between passages chew a cud. Bi-Polar artists like Greene are seldom of one mind about anything, and so they ruminate in their creations passing things from one mind to another and from one mood to another. At times they can seem contradictory and perturbing.

Graham Greene’s wife is said to have thought he should never have married. My friend and university mentor Professor Edward Sarmiento—of the same era—once mentioned to me that Greene’s British Catholic world had been at civil war over his abandonment of his Catholic wife in favor of a mistress, and from then on into a chain of affairs, while never divorcing. If sides were chosen in the tabloid heyday of this scandal, his wife had by far the better of public opinion, but still Greene kept writing and publishing with his detractors and readers all around.

Outsiders often see Catholicism as black-and-white, dogmatic, excessively structured, and predictable, while Catholics themselves are portrayed as content to be viewed as sheep. In a novelist’s eye all this can change to color, chaos, contention, and cobbling, both institutional and personal. Greene could not be described as sheepish. Whether daunted or undaunted by his own misgivings, hesitations, and crises he was more of a goat, butting sometimes haloed heads along his cobbled road, novel after novel.

As a priest in one of my own novels says, “There are times to be sheep and times to be goats.” A goatish approach to Catholicism probably makes for a better story. Both animals, by the way, are ruminants, but goats are more intelligent, colorful, and unpredictable. Greene was all these things. He could be both charming and abrasive, and always challenging, an apt example of the Chinese proverb that says a proper man is not a dish. I know of no better depiction of his many-sidedness and many moods than Shirley Hazzard’s compelling memoir Greene on Capri. To spend much time with Greene, either the man or his novels, took more than a bit of courage.  Hazzard, herself an able novelist, is up to the task, but it is always a task. An evening with Greene was never exactly fun.

Great novels are constructed from great uncertainties and strenuous guesswork, with resolution to be found somewhere down a long hallway behind a locked door if found at all. To his credit, I think, Greene resisted that foremost pitfall of so many writers of faith-based fiction: he fancied himself neither philosopher nor theologian. His novels are not thinly disguised self-help books. He remains the investigative journalist probing life no matter how unpleasant, and being anything but buoyant.

Nevertheless, for me, Greene’s internal struggles at times call Thomas Merton’s to mind. I cannot turn to one without at times thinking of the other. I doubt that either man would savor the comparison, but there it is: the monk and the man who should never have married. It’s ironic that Merton’s life ended much as it might have were he a character in a Greene novel, in a distant place among rumor and conflicting report.

The lives and writings of both men reverberate with these lines from T. S. Eliot:

We shall not cease from exploration
and the end of all our exploring
will be to arrive where we started
and know the place for the first time.

Given the rich textures and nuances of Catholicity, given its subtleties, mysteries, and possibilities, the wonder is not that it should produce such a writer as Greene. The wonder is that it has not produced more.

James Casper

James Casper

James Casper was born and grew up in southern Minnesota. Apart from living in various Minnesota locales, he has resided in Boston, St. Louis, eastern Tennessee, and London, England. He and his wife of twenty-four years have traveled extensively. Rome is one of their favorite places. He is happiest walking from lock to lock along the Thames in England. His first novel is Everywhere in Chains. You can find more of his writing at his website,

Tags: Catholic writers Graham Greene writing


  1. July 28, 2015 at 9:49 pm

    I was giving to read Green for the first time when I was in high school in a catholic school. My english teacher was a an old Jesuit priest, who dare to give us to read the best of english literature. He made read us out loud and in a kind of choir voice. I found in Green a very spiritual men and a writer who dare to ask questions regarding the human condition. He wrote an article about Buda, in which he shares all the things that he considers very enrichful of the Buda, and at the same time, he talks to Jesus telling him, that learn with the Buda teachings, but that he wil never betray him or change, he’ll be loyal to him till the end. Maybe this love declaration has to do with his love affairs, who knows, what is true, is that he was a man tormented by an spiritual feeling that make him very human, sinfully human, as we all are.

  2. July 29, 2015 at 3:03 pm

    Thank you. I too first encountered Greene in a Catholic High School, one with a strong Jesuit presence. The novel drawn to my attention was The Power and the Glory, published as The Labyrinthine Ways, its original American title, taken from the first stanza of Francis Thompson’s poem The Hound of Heaven: “I fled Him down the nights and down the days; I fled Him down the arches of the years …” Thompson’s poem resonates when one thinks of Greene and what you so well describe as his tormented spiritual feeling.

  3. August 17, 2015 at 4:18 pm

    Thank you for this thought-provoking article, Mr. Casper. The first Greene novel I read was “The Power”, but the most interesting was “The Heart of the Matter”. His screenplay for the ambiguous “The Third Man” is along the same lines. “We can’t get There on our own” seems to be a primary theme in Greene’s literary work and his life.

From the Editors

Important Information:
Opinions expressed on the Novel Thoughts weblog are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the positions of Ignatius Press. Links on this weblog to articles do not necessarily imply agreement by the author or by Ignatius Press with the contents of the articles. Links are provided to foster discussion of important issues. Readers should make their own evaluations of the contents of such articles.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.